Sunday, April 12, 2015

Carbon Sequestration using Coca-Cola

                                              Would you like a slice of lemon with your carbon sequestration?


Advocates of carbon capture (CC) and carbon sequestration (CS) have demonstrated that it is possible to capture carbon from the smokestacks of fossil fuel power plants. A more intractable problem is figuring out to store or sequester the CO
2 so that it doesn't reach the atmosphere and contribute to global warming. The ongoing work on CC and CS is of great interest to folks interested in geoengineering the planet to mitigate global warming, as techniques that can successfully remove CO2 from power plant exhausts and store it might also be applicable to the larger problem of removing excess CO2 from the earth's atmosphere in order to geoengineer earth's climate.

Thus it was with some interest that I read about a new proposal to divert CO
2 captured from power plant exhaust stacks into normal industrial uses, including the carbonation of fizzy drinks like coca cola, pepsi, ginger ale, soda water, beer, Moscato, etc. So far Australia is taking the lead on this particular problem:


'Australia has worked closely with other countries which rely heavily on fossil fuels to investigate opportunities to utilise CO2 in products such as carbonated drinks and plastics.....’

I can understand how you might "sequester" captured CO
2 in plastics, because plastics are inert and almost indestructible if they aren't burned, but I'm not sure the people thinking of storing CO2 in plastics have actually thought through just how much .....plastic.....they would have to make and sequester to really make a dent in the amount of CO2 released by fossil fuel use. The combustion of fossil fuels currently releases about 40 billion tons of CO2 into the atmosphere each year, and if you could capture it all then after 25 years you'd have something over a trillion tons (1,000,000,000 tons) of CO2 to store in plastic.  For comparison, the Great Pyramid of Giza in Egypt weighs something like 6.5 million tons, so after 25 years of CC and CS by converting CO2 into plastic you'd have created something like 153,846 full size plastic replicas of the Great Pyramid of Giza, which you'd have to guard forever to prevent them from catching fire and returning all that CO2 to the atmosphere.

And trying to sequester CO
2 by adding it to Coca Cola and other fizzy drinks is even more problematical. When people drink Coca-Cola much of the CO2 that makes the drink fizzy is quickly released back to the atmosphere through various kinds of human gaseous emissions. Even worse, some of it is converted into methane, a greenhouse gas 20 times more powerful then CO2.  I suppose someone could devise additional carbon capture systems that you could strap on to various human orifices to absorb the CO2 and methane emitted from people who drink Coca-Cola, but if that CO2 is in turn going to be sequestered by reintroducing it into Coca Cola again, as the Australians are suggesting, then there is hardly any point to the entire carbon capture and carbon sequestration process.

Thursday, April 9, 2015

A Non-partisan Review of Global Warming





Liberals believe in Global Warming, conservatives don't---thats the stereotype.

But Global Warming isn't a religion that people either believe in or don't---its a collection of scientific data organized into a scientific hypothesis. The acceptance or rejection of the ideas that human activities are causing climate change and Global Warming shouldn't be a matter or belief or faith---it should depend 100% on the data.   It should be non-partisan.

Recently Ronald Bailey, the science correspondent for a "conservative" magazine named "Reason" recently wrote a very interesting review of the data that he believes provides incontrovertible evidence for Global Warming:

1. Atmospheric CO
2 has increased from 280 parts per million in the late 18th century to around 400 ppm today.

2. All of the global temperature datasets from both weather stations and satellites show the Earth has warmed.  Just since the 1950s  instrumental records suggest that surface temperatures have increased by about +0.9 C° (1.6 F°). Satellite data shows that over the past 35 years global temperatures have increased by about 0.5° C (0.9°F).

3. Global Climate Models (GCMs) predict man-made warming due to increasing CO
2 in the atmosphere will reduce differences between daytime and nighttime temperatures. The data show this is happening in the United States, China, Spain, and other regions.

4. GCMs predict global warming will result in more heatwaves, and indeed heat waves have become more common since the 1950s.

5. GCMs predict the warm temperatures of spring will arrive sooner and the cool temperatures of fall will begin later, and the data shows that spring in Europe arrives about 3 days earlier and average date for the entire Northern Hemisphere is about 4 days earlier. The fall is also starting later, resulting in a longer growing season.

6. Over the last 40 years there has been a 7 - 11% decrease in spring snow cover, consistent with with climate model predictions.

7. GCMs predict that Global Warming will be greater in Arctic regions then at lower latitudes, and Arctic summer melt season has lengthened at a rate of 5 days per decade over the last 35 years. Arctic temperatures are rising at 0.6° C per decade, about 4 times the global average.

8. Warming Arctic temperatures are predicted to cause massive glacier melt, and the Greenland ice sheet has been losing mass at a rate of 34 gigatons per year over the last 35 years, with the rate of ice loss jumping up sevenfold since 2002 to an estimated 215 gigatons per year.

9. GCM models predicted that Arctic sea ice and would thin and the extent of sea ice would decrease, and since 1980 Arctic sea ice extent has been decreasing at rate of ca. 3.8 percent per decade, a value significantly in excess of the worst case prediction scenario.

10. A warming atmosphere should be characterized by higher average humidity, and satellite studies from 2005 and 2014 found this is occurring. However, this factor does not preclude Global Warming producing intense droughts in some localities, like those currently hitting California, Taiwan and Argentina.

11. GCM models predict the Earth's oceans will warm, and numerous studies show significant warming of the oceans, with as much as 90 percent of the heat trapped by atmospheric Greenhouse gases currently being stored there.


Finally, after showing that the warming of the Earth seen over the last 100 years is fully consistent with predictions of global warming due to CO
2 releases from fossil fuel combustion, Ronald Bailey notes recent predictions that the rate of warming of the Earth will soon rise to 0.25°C per decade ----- a remarkable and ultimately rather unpleasant rate of warming to contemplate.

 Given the high level of success achieved by past predictions of the effects of global warming, I sincerely hope both liberals and conservatives take these new predictions quite seriously.  Since the prospect of continued rapid warming is ultimately untenable we may be approaching the time when there is no option but to try some non-partisan Planetary Geoengineering to mitigate future climate change.

Wednesday, April 8, 2015

Methane gas blowhole formation in Siberia proceeding ad infinitum


                                               Smaller methane craters now forming ad infinitum

Russia Today (RT) reports that smaller "baby" pits are now appearing around the margins of the large "gas blow holes" discovered last year on the Yamal Peninsula of northern Siberia.   The large central gas blowholes attracted global attention when they appeared, as they may be an indicator that Global Warming has progressed sufficiently that it is causing permafrost in Siberia to degrade and release large amounts of methane. 

The new report from RT that many smaller pits are now forming around the margins of the larger pits is consistent with the idea that the methane gas blow holes are forming as the result of large scale thermal degradation of permafrost.  Some have suggested the gas blow holes were "one-off" events connected to oil and gas drilling or some other non-climatic mechanism. but the creation of pit after pit in the months after the formation of the big central pit is more consistent with warming of permafrost as a consequence of Global Warming.  If this pattern repeats, then in coming years more large gas blow holes will form, and then more smaller gas blow blow holes and even smaller collapse pits will form around them,  until parts of the Siberian landscape begin to look like Swiss cheese.

The prospect of the creation of more and more central gas blow holes, followed by many many smaller gas blowholes and pits spreading across the Siberian landscape reminds me of Jonathan Swift's famous (1733) poem about fleas:

So nat'ralists observe, a flea 
Has smaller fleas that on him prey; 
And these have smaller fleas to bite 'em.   
And so proceeds Ad infinitum.

Here's my version



In far Siberia gas blow holes form 
When the permafrost gets too warm 
And then small blow holes do surround 
As still more methane leaves the ground 

Augustus De Morgan borrowed from Swift's idea to write a similar verse in 1872

Great fleas have little fleas upon their backs to bite 'em, 
And little fleas have lesser fleas, and so ad infinitum.

And here is my variation on De Morgan's flea poem reset for the methane gas blowholes now beginning to spread across Siberia.

Great gas blow holes have little gas blow holes beside 'em 
And little holes have lesser holes, and so ad infinitum

Tuesday, April 7, 2015

Is Global Warming Killing Your Lawn?

                                                               Truthiness from the New Yorker

The Borowitz report in the New Yorker magazine recently asked: What does it take to get Americans to think about Global Warming?  The article cites a new survey that shows that while Americans are unconcerned by predictions of rising sea levels, the destruction of Arctic sea ice and polar bear habitats, and the appearance of larger and larger cyclones and hurricanes, people in California are freaking out because the drought is turning their lawns brown.    


“We are being forced to create a front lawn out of stones and, yes, cacti.  I’m not sure that this is a world I would want to leave to my children.”  
                            --Harland Dorrinson (Sacramento).

“Right now we’re looking at a situation where we have to choose between saving our climbing hydrangeas or our roses,  We are no longer living like humans.”
                           --Tracy Klugian (San Diego).

And a  nice lady named Carol Foyler, after watching the lawn in front of her ranch house in San Mateo turn from a gorgeous green to a hideous brown during California’s drought, said she blamed scientists “for failing to warn us of the true cost of climate change.”


“They always said that polar bears would starve to death.  OK, I can accept that.  But they never told us our lawns would look like crap.”

Monday, April 6, 2015

Five Psychological Gimmicks to Deal With Global Warming That Almost All Start with D

Analyze THIS!

In a recent book entitled "What We Think About When We Try Not to Think about Global Warming" the psychologist Per Espen Stoknes identified five psychological gimmicks  that people use to avoid taking action to prevent climate change.   The five reasons that Per Stoknes comes up with are straight out of the  the kind of "touchy-feely" psychobabble that provides so much amusement in comedy movies about dysfunctional couples in relationship counseling.  

DISTANCE 

Per Stoknes called his first psychological gimmick "distance" ---inspired by the similarities between global warming and a girlfriend who might be acting "distant."  By this he means that Greenhouse Warming seems to be acting remote --- like its mind is on the Arctic maybe, so people can't emotionally connect with it.   

DOOM vs. REALITY

Per Stoknes believes that framing global warming as an oncoming vision of doom that will result in economic hardships and personal losses, and a problem without a practical solution makes people tune it all out.  Here Per Stoknes seems fundamentally misunderstand the problem.  The scientific predictions of the effects of future global warming are what they are---they can't be changed so they sound better.  

COGNITVE DISSONANCE vs. GUILT

Per Stoknes complains that he suffers from cognitive dissonance, because he continues to drive his car, eat meat, fly on airplanes, and do other things that he knows contribute to climate change.  A less fancy word for the emotion Mr. Stoknes is feeling is guilt---the man feels guilty because he think he is a climate criminal who is personally responsible for melting the Arctic Ice Cap and killing off the Walrus.

DENIAL

Mr. Stoknes believes that many people are "in denial" about climate change.  By "denial" he means people can't emotionally connect with Global Warming, i.e. more or less the same thing as he meant when he said "distance."  As far as I can tell he added a gimmick called "denial" so he'd have five big psychological gimmicks instead of merely four.

iDENTITY

Prof. Stoknes' fifth gimmick is what he calls "iDentity" [sic].   Note that the preceding four gimmicks all started with the letter "D" so Prof. Stoknes has intentionally misspelled the word identity as iDentity so as to have all five psychological gimmicks start with the letter "D".  Wow---that is really profound ---  all five psychological gimmicks start with "D"!!!! if you only misspell one of them!!!!!     

By iDentity Prof. Stoknes means that people who are "conservative" don't believe in global warming because people who are "liberal" do.  

------------------------

 Of course the premise of Per Stoknes' book is absurd, as its already too late to prevent climate change----the real question is what can we do to stop Global Warming.  I await his next book...."What We Think About When We Try Not to Think About Geoengineering"

Sunday, April 5, 2015

Russians Publish First Scientific Report on Siberian Methane Explosion Pits


       The first scientific report on the methane gas explosion pits in Siberia has just been released

Russian scientists have just published the first scientific report on the mysterious pits that have recently been discovered on the Yamal Peninsula and other parts of northern Siberia. The pits are in a remote part of Siberia, and the scientists were only able to visit one pit (shown above).  


The Russian scientists came to several stunning conclusions:

1.  They believe that these pits are a completely new terrestrial landform that has never before been observed in Siberia or elsewhere on the earth.   This implies that some entirely new earth process or activity is now occurring in Siberia.

2.   They hypothesize that the crater and its surrounding debris field was created when large quantities of methane gas were released from organic rich horizons in the underground permafrost.  Eventually enough methane was released that gas pressures in the subsurface became high enough to blast out a crater and eject debris up to 100 m from the rim of the central pit.  

3.   They conclude that warmer ground temperatures in central Siberia are responsible for destabilizing the permafrost and are causing the release of large amounts of methane gas from the frozen sediments, resulting in over-pressurized zones rich in methane gas that eventually blast their way out of the permafrost.  


This is bad news because methane is an even more powerful greenhouse gas then CO2, and Arctic permafrost contains a staggering “1.5 trillion tons of frozen carbon” much of which would be released as methane if the permafrost becomes destabilized. 

If warming the permafrost is what is causing the Siberian methane gas eruptions, then additional warming of the permafrost will cause additional methane gas eruptions.   And unless a successful geoengineering program is started soon, Siberia and the rest of the Arctic are on track to see 10°-20° of additional warming by the year 2100.

Friday, April 3, 2015

Why 350.org should endorse Climate Geoengineering

                                                   
                Geoengineering is the only way to reduce atmospheric CO2 to 350 ppm


One of the most interesting organizations mobilizing to build public support for measures against Global Warming is called 350.org. Founded by Bill McKibben, the author of the important book "The End of Nature", 350.org takes its inspiration from scientific studies by Dr. James Hansen that show that dangerous levels of global warming can be avoided if atmospheric CO
2 can be kept below 350 ppm. Unfortunately, as shown in the diagram above, atmospheric CO2 is currently just going over 400 ppm.  And even more unfortunately, unlike the diagram above, CO2 is on track to continue rising to 500 or even 600 ppm---levels last seen on earth millions of years ago when the planet was too warm for ice sheets and sea level was 100 feet higher than now.

350.org got started in 2008, and since then has focused on organizing "days of action" where people can come together in mass demonstrations in support of stopping climate change and reducing atmospheric CO
2 concentrations to 350 ppm.  There have been a series of mass demonstrations including the International Day of Climate Action in 2009, the Global Work Party in 2010, Moving Planet in 2011, Climate Impacts Day in 2012, and the People's Climate March held in New York City in 2014, the largest anti-Global Warming mass demonstration in history.  In the short term 350.org works on campaigns to fight coal fired electrical plants, stop the construction of oil pipelines, and to reduce the use of fossil fuels and concomitant release of CO2 into the atmosphere but their stated goal is the reduction of atmospheric CO2 in the atmosphere to 350 ppm.

Curiously, for an organization based on scientific concepts derived from the work of Dr. James Hansen, 350.org seems oblivious to the fact that none of their activities will return the earth's atmosphere to 350 ppm CO
2. Many scientific studies show that the residence time of CO2 in the atmosphere is ca. 800-1000 years. This means that the current level of over 400 ppm will continue for hundreds of years into the future, and if new CO2 continues to be added to the atmosphere so CO2 levels rise to 500 or 600 ppm, then those higher levels of CO2 in the atmosphere will be present for the next 800-1000 years.

I completely agree with Dr. James Hansen and 350.org that it is highly desirable to reduce atmospheric CO
2 concentrations to 350 ppm. But how can this goal be achieved?  It seems obvious to me that that only way to stop CO2 from increasing in the atmosphere, and the only way to reduce atmospheric CO2 to 350 ppm, is to develop and apply an appropriate geoengineering method. And yet many climate activists oppose geoengineering just as strongly as they oppose ongoing global warming. This is an unfortunate thing, because the only way to reduce atmosphere CO2 is geonginering. There is no other way to do it.

I therefore encourage the people at 350.org and other climate change groups to consider supporting development of ways to geoengineer earth's climate. It may seem improbable to some that geoengineering can reduce CO
2 in the atmosphere, but that is precisely the goal of my own CO2 Antarctic Pumpdown geoengineering proposal as well as several other geoengineering ideas.  If geoengineering isn't attempted, then CO2 will build up in the atmosphere for hundreds of years---creating an impossible situation.  And, as Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's famous character Sherlock Holmes once said:
'How often have I said to you that when you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth?'