Monday, April 6, 2015

Five Psychological Gimmicks to Deal With Global Warming That Almost All Start with D

Analyze THIS!

In a recent book entitled "What We Think About When We Try Not to Think about Global Warming" the psychologist Per Espen Stoknes identified five psychological gimmicks  that people use to avoid taking action to prevent climate change.   The five reasons that Per Stoknes comes up with are straight out of the  the kind of "touchy-feely" psychobabble that provides so much amusement in comedy movies about dysfunctional couples in relationship counseling.  

DISTANCE 

Per Stoknes called his first psychological gimmick "distance" ---inspired by the similarities between global warming and a girlfriend who might be acting "distant."  By this he means that Greenhouse Warming seems to be acting remote --- like its mind is on the Arctic maybe, so people can't emotionally connect with it.   

DOOM vs. REALITY

Per Stoknes believes that framing global warming as an oncoming vision of doom that will result in economic hardships and personal losses, and a problem without a practical solution makes people tune it all out.  Here Per Stoknes seems fundamentally misunderstand the problem.  The scientific predictions of the effects of future global warming are what they are---they can't be changed so they sound better.  

COGNITVE DISSONANCE vs. GUILT

Per Stoknes complains that he suffers from cognitive dissonance, because he continues to drive his car, eat meat, fly on airplanes, and do other things that he knows contribute to climate change.  A less fancy word for the emotion Mr. Stoknes is feeling is guilt---the man feels guilty because he think he is a climate criminal who is personally responsible for melting the Arctic Ice Cap and killing off the Walrus.

DENIAL

Mr. Stoknes believes that many people are "in denial" about climate change.  By "denial" he means people can't emotionally connect with Global Warming, i.e. more or less the same thing as he meant when he said "distance."  As far as I can tell he added a gimmick called "denial" so he'd have five big psychological gimmicks instead of merely four.

iDENTITY

Prof. Stoknes' fifth gimmick is what he calls "iDentity" [sic].   Note that the preceding four gimmicks all started with the letter "D" so Prof. Stoknes has intentionally misspelled the word identity as iDentity so as to have all five psychological gimmicks start with the letter "D".  Wow---that is really profound ---  all five psychological gimmicks start with "D"!!!! if you only misspell one of them!!!!!     

By iDentity Prof. Stoknes means that people who are "conservative" don't believe in global warming because people who are "liberal" do.  

------------------------

 Of course the premise of Per Stoknes' book is absurd, as its already too late to prevent climate change----the real question is what can we do to stop Global Warming.  I await his next book...."What We Think About When We Try Not to Think About Geoengineering"

Sunday, April 5, 2015

Russians Publish First Scientific Report on Siberian Methane Explosion Pits


       The first scientific report on the methane gas explosion pits in Siberia has just been released

Russian scientists have just published the first scientific report on the mysterious pits that have recently been discovered on the Yamal Peninsula and other parts of northern Siberia. The pits are in a remote part of Siberia, and the scientists were only able to visit one pit (shown above).  


The Russian scientists came to several stunning conclusions:

1.  They believe that these pits are a completely new terrestrial landform that has never before been observed in Siberia or elsewhere on the earth.   This implies that some entirely new earth process or activity is now occurring in Siberia.

2.   They hypothesize that the crater and its surrounding debris field was created when large quantities of methane gas were released from organic rich horizons in the underground permafrost.  Eventually enough methane was released that gas pressures in the subsurface became high enough to blast out a crater and eject debris up to 100 m from the rim of the central pit.  

3.   They conclude that warmer ground temperatures in central Siberia are responsible for destabilizing the permafrost and are causing the release of large amounts of methane gas from the frozen sediments, resulting in over-pressurized zones rich in methane gas that eventually blast their way out of the permafrost.  


This is bad news because methane is an even more powerful greenhouse gas then CO2, and Arctic permafrost contains a staggering “1.5 trillion tons of frozen carbon” much of which would be released as methane if the permafrost becomes destabilized. 

If warming the permafrost is what is causing the Siberian methane gas eruptions, then additional warming of the permafrost will cause additional methane gas eruptions.   And unless a successful geoengineering program is started soon, Siberia and the rest of the Arctic are on track to see 10°-20° of additional warming by the year 2100.

Friday, April 3, 2015

Why 350.org should endorse Climate Geoengineering

                                                   
                Geoengineering is the only way to reduce atmospheric CO2 to 350 ppm


One of the most interesting organizations mobilizing to build public support for measures against Global Warming is called 350.org. Founded by Bill McKibben, the author of the important book "The End of Nature", 350.org takes its inspiration from scientific studies by Dr. James Hansen that show that dangerous levels of global warming can be avoided if atmospheric CO
2 can be kept below 350 ppm. Unfortunately, as shown in the diagram above, atmospheric CO2 is currently just going over 400 ppm.  And even more unfortunately, unlike the diagram above, CO2 is on track to continue rising to 500 or even 600 ppm---levels last seen on earth millions of years ago when the planet was too warm for ice sheets and sea level was 100 feet higher than now.

350.org got started in 2008, and since then has focused on organizing "days of action" where people can come together in mass demonstrations in support of stopping climate change and reducing atmospheric CO
2 concentrations to 350 ppm.  There have been a series of mass demonstrations including the International Day of Climate Action in 2009, the Global Work Party in 2010, Moving Planet in 2011, Climate Impacts Day in 2012, and the People's Climate March held in New York City in 2014, the largest anti-Global Warming mass demonstration in history.  In the short term 350.org works on campaigns to fight coal fired electrical plants, stop the construction of oil pipelines, and to reduce the use of fossil fuels and concomitant release of CO2 into the atmosphere but their stated goal is the reduction of atmospheric CO2 in the atmosphere to 350 ppm.

Curiously, for an organization based on scientific concepts derived from the work of Dr. James Hansen, 350.org seems oblivious to the fact that none of their activities will return the earth's atmosphere to 350 ppm CO
2. Many scientific studies show that the residence time of CO2 in the atmosphere is ca. 800-1000 years. This means that the current level of over 400 ppm will continue for hundreds of years into the future, and if new CO2 continues to be added to the atmosphere so CO2 levels rise to 500 or 600 ppm, then those higher levels of CO2 in the atmosphere will be present for the next 800-1000 years.

I completely agree with Dr. James Hansen and 350.org that it is highly desirable to reduce atmospheric CO
2 concentrations to 350 ppm. But how can this goal be achieved?  It seems obvious to me that that only way to stop CO2 from increasing in the atmosphere, and the only way to reduce atmospheric CO2 to 350 ppm, is to develop and apply an appropriate geoengineering method. And yet many climate activists oppose geoengineering just as strongly as they oppose ongoing global warming. This is an unfortunate thing, because the only way to reduce atmosphere CO2 is geonginering. There is no other way to do it.

I therefore encourage the people at 350.org and other climate change groups to consider supporting development of ways to geoengineer earth's climate. It may seem improbable to some that geoengineering can reduce CO
2 in the atmosphere, but that is precisely the goal of my own CO2 Antarctic Pumpdown geoengineering proposal as well as several other geoengineering ideas.  If geoengineering isn't attempted, then CO2 will build up in the atmosphere for hundreds of years---creating an impossible situation.  And, as Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's famous character Sherlock Holmes once said:
'How often have I said to you that when you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth?'
     


Monday, March 30, 2015

Global Warming and Praying to the Raven


Make prayers to the Raven

In June 2014 the Atlantic Magazine published an interesting article entitled "When Global Warming Kills your God", about conflicts between the traditional beliefs of native Alaskans and modern environmental laws and new problems being caused by global warming in the Bethel area of western Alaska.  Just 50 years ago most native Alaskans in Bethel and throughout the state lived almost entirely on things like whale meat, fish, moose, caribou, birds and birds eggs, berries, and anything else they could find, catch or kill around their villages.  Native culture and native religion was intertwined with seasonally driven shifts from fishing to hunting to gathering, and with the animistic belief that the animals around them in Alaska were intelligent and spiritual creatures much like themselves.  For instance the Koyukon People of Alaska traditionally prayed to Ravens and believed that in the "Distant Time" many animals could speak Koyukon, and people had been transformed into animals by magic.   These old gods were largely abandoned by native Alaskans when Christianity was introduced into Alaska during the 19th century.

Today, most native Alaskans get a large proportion of their calories from store bought food.  Almost every native village has a small store where people can buy coca-cola, ice cream bars, fiery hot cheetos, cans of spaghetti and other necessities of modern American life.  But almost every native village also has a group of people who remember the way their parents lived off the land, and would like to return to that lifestyle today.  

However, in the modern world, things like hunting that were once both traditional and spiritual are now controlled by state and federal regulations.  There are limits on how many fish can be taken and when hunting can be done and when it can't be done, and some things that were formerly hunted, like whales, are specifically protected by laws.    Through a long struggle, native people in Alaska have won the right to continue some of their traditional subsistence practices.  Aleut people in northern Alaska have returned to hunting whales in the fall.  People along the Koyukuk River are again allowed to collect the eggs of geese who migrate to their region.  And in many parts of Alaska recent court rulings and special regulations issued from the State of Alaska allow native Alaskan to catch large numbers of salmon with nets, as they have done for thousands of years.

The struggle for traditional hunting and fishing rights being carried out by native Alaskans has so far brought them into conflict only with various state and federal agencies that enforce environmental regulations and hunting and fishing laws.  When arrests are made and the cases go to court, the courts are often sympathetic to the traditional practices of native people.   IN some cases the legal cases that go to court invoke the ancient animistic beliefs of native Alaskans as a way to show a special relationship exists between native Alaskans and the natural world around them.

Global Warming may soon introduce another difficulty as warming temperatures is likely to cause dramatic changes to the Alaska landscape.  Shrubs are starting to grow where there was only tundra, and forests are advance into areas formerly dominated by shrubs.  Permafrost is melting, and water temperatures are warming both in rivers and in coastal waters.  Sea Ice that once lasted into the summer around the coastline of northern Alaska is now melting in the spring and retreating far out into the Arctic Ocean.  The future effects of events like this on the number and range of birds, animals and fish in Alaska can't be predicted with certainty, but  almost certainly things will be very different when Global Warming starts to change the environment and force animals to move or adapt to new environemtnts, and in some places,  kills off the old gods entirely.

Sunday, March 29, 2015

Defy Global Warming with Geoengineering

                                                                 Defy Global Warming!


Bill McKibben, author of the book "The End of Nature", believes that humankind has to choose between two paths forward in dealing with climate change.   One path he calls "the defiant reflex" while the other alternative is a "more humble" way of living.  The defiant reflex refers to a reluctance to accept the scientific facts about global warming and a refusal to make changes that would reduce CO2 emissions from fossil fuels. Mr. McKibben writes:
“The choice of doing nothing – of continuing to burn ever more oil and coal will lead us, if not straight to hell, then straight to a place with similar temperatures.”

McKibben's preferred option is for affluent western countries to move to a more "humble" way of living that requires less consumption of fossil fuels. Mr. McKibben believes that an over dependence on material possessions in the Western world is the reason why more people don't support steps to reduce the carbon emissions in the US and other western countries. He writes:

“the end of nature sours all of my material pleasures...... And yet it is toward such a world that our belief in endless material advancement hurries us.”

McKibben's book was written 26 years ago in 1989, during a period of optimism about the possibility of bringing about voluntary global reductions in CO
2 emissions. "Earth Day" celebrations then attracted enormous crowds across the USA, the UN Kyoto Climate Accords had just been ratified two years earlier in Japan, and a general consensus seemed to exist that the planet was making progress towards combatting Greenhouse Warming.

The situation is far different in 2015. We know now that the Kyoto Accords failed at reducing CO
2 emissions. Global CO2 emissions are far higher now then they were in 1987 and there is little hope of reducing them soon. The long promised post-Kyoto UN climate treaty that was supposed to introduced binding accords on CO2 emissions was abandoned after friction arose between President Obama and the Chinese delegation at the 2010 Copenhagen Conference.  The new goal in climate negotiations is to set "voluntary" targets as was done in the earlier Kyoto Accords that failed to reduce CO2 emissions. And the belief that the main problem in reducing CO2 emissions is convincing affluent people in the west to be a little less affluent must now confront the new reality that the greatest amounts of CO2 emissions now come from non-western countries like China and India that are trying to improve the lives of two billion impoverished people.

Fortunately there is another way to defy global warming other than doing nothing. There may even be a way to reverse global warming. The scientific study of methods that can remove CO
2 from the atmosphere and mitigate and perhaps even reduce global warming is called "geoengineering." 

 Geoengineering wouldn't be necessary if the the political leaders of countries around the world were able to agree on a treaty to reduce global CO2 emissions--but they aren't. Geoengineering wouldn't be necessary if every person on earth would voluntarily reduce their own carbon footprint -- but we won't.

There is now only one way to reduce the CO
2 in the atmosphere, and thats geoengineering.  McKibben's 1989 definition of defiance of global warming is dead wrong ---- defiance of global warming isn't doing nothing---defiance is doing everything possible to reduce global warming, up to and including geoengineering the climate.

Thursday, March 26, 2015

Atmospheric CO2 is killing the trees in the Amazon Rain Forest



Recent research shows that as more CO
2 is added to the atmosphere by the human combustion of fossil fuels, the high levels of CO2 in the atmosphere are killing the trees in the Amazon Rain Forest. This is a stunning development as it shows that several assumptions that have been made about Global Warming and Geoengineering are wrong.

Human use of fossil fuels currently releases about 35 billion tons of CO2 into the atmosphere per year and about 8-9 billion tons of that is absorbed into trees and other terrestrial carbon sinks. Tropical forests took about 4 billion tons, with 2 billions tons of CO2 being absorbed annually just into the Amazon Rain Forest.  Hopes have been raised that planting more trees might be a good way to geoengineer the climate of the earth.  Those hopes now appear to be misplaced.

Its long been known that more CO2 in the air results in plants having a higher growth rate. Many studies have shown that trees in the Amazon Rainforest are growing faster, and until recently they have been pumping down about two billion tons of CO2 from the atmosphere. But now huge numbers of trees in the Amazon Rain Forest are dying and the amount of CO2 being absorbed in the Amazon region has dropped by over 50%. It appears that in addition to accelerating tree growth, extra CO2 from the atmosphere is accelerating the life cycle of trees so that they die sooner.

The mortality rate of trees in the Amazon Rain Forest has gone up by more than third in the last 30 years. And when the trees die, the CO
2 that has been stored in the wood, the leaves, and the roots is released back into the atmosphere as the dead tree rots. Multiply that by millions of trees dying prematurely because of CO2, and the total effect on the earth's carbon cycle is huge.  Much more CO2 will remain in the atmosphere. 

And mostly likely the effect is probably not limited to trees in the Amazon Rain Forest---most likely every tree on earth is responding to higher levels of CO2  in the atmosphere by growing fast, maturing sooner, and dying faster.


Wednesday, March 25, 2015

Climate Change Kooks Fall Out


                                                              Kook vs. Kook

There is an old saying "thieves fall out".  It means that people who are by nature thieves will find it difficult to cooperate with other thieves---their instincts have a nasty habit of taking over and they wind up stealing the loot from each other.  Lots of  movies play on this theme, including a film noir classic from the 1930s entitled "Thieves Fall Out" and a made-for-TV movie from the 1980s entitled "When Thieves Fall Out".  Jessica Fletcher solved a murder mystery in Cabot Cove during an episode entitled "When Thieves Fall Out."  The same idea occurs in hundreds of heist movies like "The Italian Job", "Snatch" "Lock Stock" and Two Smoking Barrels" and "A Simple Plan."  Some of these movies are classics---- who doesn't love watching a movie where thieves try to outwit one-another?  The "thieves fall out" idea even shows up in Samurai movies like "Yojimbo" and its a common theme in Western movies ---think of any of the Clint Eastward "Man with no Name" movies. 

Everybody expects thieves to fall out.  But what about kooks?  Do people with weird and bizarre ideas rub along OK with other when they get together, or do kooks fall out the same way thieves fall out?

There is popular late night radio show in the United States called "Coast to Coast" which features an endless parade of people who claim to talk to ghosts, take spaceship rides with aliens, travel through time, have inside knowledge of secret societies out to control the world, etc., etc.  By any measure these people are kooks, and you'd think all these folks would have a hard time getting along, but its amazing how people who think the pyramids in Egypt were built by space aliens have nothing but nice things to say about people who think the pyramids in Egypt were built by time travelers.   These folks all manage to be patient and considerate with one-another,  in spite of their wildly different views.

But climate change kooks aren't quite as agreeable as time travelers and space aliens.   Recently people from "Geoengineering Watch" who believe that a secret cabal of scientists is already secretly geoengineering the earth's climate to intentionally create global warming met with some people from the "Near Term Human Extinction" movement who believe that global warming is going to be so severe that the human race will go extinct in the very near future.  You'd think these two groups would find some common ground, but they very quickly fell out over their view of the future.  Geoengineering Watch maintains that if only the secret lair of the secret cabal of scientists who are supposedly already secretly geoengineering earth's climate can be discovered, then their nefarious scheme can be stopped in time to save the earth.  This was unacceptable to the people in the Near Term Human Extinction moment, who have already give up all hope and resigned themselves to their imminent demise.  

Personally, I hope these two groups meet again and again to work things out.  Surely people who have convinced themselves that the world is about to end and humans will go extinct can find room to blame it all on a secret cabal of scientists, and surely people who believe that a secret cabal of scientists hidden in a secret lair are secretly destroying the earth's climate can see their way to believing that imminent doom is upon them.  These two groups have much to learn from one-another.